Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

MPOA Highschool Science

Collapse
X
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    MPOA Highschool Science

    If I were to chose one of the highschool science course for my son to take online, which would be the best? In other words, what course should I reserve for online instruction and then complete the rest of his science with me at home?
    Katie

    2018/2019 5th year with MP
    DS 9th, DD 6th, DD 2nd: attending a classical prep school 3 days/week using mostly MP.
    Twin DD's 6: home with me and loving MPK!

    #2
    Re: MPOA Highschool Science

    Katie,

    I think some of that answer will depend on your background. I have a mechanical engineering degree, so we are using the Novare ASPC book at home this year. We aren't very far into the book, but it isn't bad yet. I might recommend the introductory physics text as it uses the same experiments for the physics portion and doesn't overlap with the chemistry book. Memoria Press now has streaming videos for biology (but lesson plans/tests/study guide aren't quite ready) so there is help coming for biology. Chemistry is where I plan to have my daughter take an online science class. I say that because I don't see homeschool helps from MP for chemistry in time for your son or my daughter given how much time it has taken to develop the biology program. I haven't had chemistry since freshman year in college so I think my daughter will get much more out of chemistry with someone who has had time to prepare explain it to them. I think classes for any of the sciences would be good, but another two day/week class didn't fit into our schedule this year.
    Dorinda

    DD 15 - 10th with MPOA(Biology, Novel, Material Logic/Rhetoric ), Lukeion (Greek3, Latin 3)
    DS 13 - 8A with MPOA(Third Form and composition)
    DS 10 - 5M
    DS 5 - K with AAR3

    Comment


      #3
      Re: MPOA Highschool Science

      Originally posted by Mom2mthj View Post
      Katie,

      I think some of that answer will depend on your background. I have a mechanical engineering degree, so we are using the Novare ASPC book at home this year. We aren't very far into the book, but it isn't bad yet. I might recommend the introductory physics text as it uses the same experiments for the physics portion and doesn't overlap with the chemistry book. Memoria Press now has streaming videos for biology (but lesson plans/tests/study guide aren't quite ready) so there is help coming for biology. Chemistry is where I plan to have my daughter take an online science class. I say that because I don't see homeschool helps from MP for chemistry in time for your son or my daughter given how much time it has taken to develop the biology program. I haven't had chemistry since freshman year in college so I think my daughter will get much more out of chemistry with someone who has had time to prepare explain it to them. I think classes for any of the sciences would be good, but another two day/week class didn't fit into our schedule this year.
      Dorinda,
      Thanks for your thoughts. I certainly do not have a physics background with my Research Psych degree. I will do much better with Biology and A&P. However, my son has a big interest and talent in understanding physics and engineering and I see him going that path post highschool if he doesnt go to seminary. So Id like to be sure to have him well prepared, just in case. Id prefer he do ASPC course over the Intro Class, staying in line with Novare suggested Accelerated science and Math sequence, but I want to be able to help him if need be. Hmmm. Ill have to think about this.

      Thanks!
      Last edited by Katie; 01-11-2018, 10:01 AM. Reason: Silly auto correct
      Katie

      2018/2019 5th year with MP
      DS 9th, DD 6th, DD 2nd: attending a classical prep school 3 days/week using mostly MP.
      Twin DD's 6: home with me and loving MPK!

      Comment


        #4
        Re: MPOA Highschool Science

        Katie,
        Do you have any local resources for high school science? Tutorial? Dual-enrollment? Can he take a math/science class at a local private school? Do you know anyone else in this pinch with whom you could trade homeschool teaching duties? Just trying to help brainstorm options. For me the issue is both my background and the time needed to prep/teach. Even if I could do a class, I have to judge if it will realistically get done (and how well) if we do it at home.

        If I recall you are going to be mobile, right? I'm sure that changes everything.
        Festina lentē,
        Jessica P

        2018-2019 7th MP Year, 9th Homeschooling
        Interweaving home, cottage school, & MPOA
        DS MPOA Henle 2, 9A -- DD 7A -- DD 4A -- DS 1st

        Highlands Latin Nashville Cottage School
        www.nashvillelatinschool.com

        Comment


          #5
          Re: MPOA Highschool Science

          Originally posted by pickandgrin View Post
          Katie,
          Do you have any local resources for high school science? Tutorial? Dual-enrollment? Can he take a math/science class at a local private school? Do you know anyone else in this pinch with whom you could trade homeschool teaching duties? Just trying to help brainstorm options. For me the issue is both my background and the time needed to prep/teach. Even if I could do a class, I have to judge if it will realistically get done (and how well) if we do it at home.

          If I recall you are going to be mobile, right? I'm sure that changes everything.
          Good morning, Jessica!

          Thanks for brainstorming with me. We have considered dual enrollment at our local Community College his junior and senior year for those higher level classes, but it does depend where we are and if we are mobile. You bring up a good point about teaching and prep. I do need to think about my prep time in what seems to be an already stretched thin day of teaching.
          Katie

          2018/2019 5th year with MP
          DS 9th, DD 6th, DD 2nd: attending a classical prep school 3 days/week using mostly MP.
          Twin DD's 6: home with me and loving MPK!

          Comment


            #6
            Re: MPOA Highschool Science

            Katie,

            If biology is your personal strength I would suggest starting there instead of the introductory physics book (or ASPC). ASPC and physics first is great, but realistically it does add in an extra year to a typical high school science sequence. What I really like about Novare is they pare the material down to a level that kids can actually master in a year. As much as I love science it tends to go a bit slower around here because it requires more of my time. I would suggest purchasing the MP streaming video even though you could teach it. I think Tanya said the biology guide would be done by fall. Your time is valuable and those videos will help him keep on track even if you are busy. We used something similar for algebra for similar reasons...my daughter didn't want to have to wait around for a lesson. We did a biology lab intensive this fall with college prep science (formerly Landry academy) for biology because they were in our area and it was important to me that she have some hands on experience for labs. Chemistry through MPOA could be a good fit. I don't know that he needs the advanced track for chemistry. I would spend the physics time on a trig based year and a Calc based year. You have a bit of time to figure those out ;-)
            Dorinda

            DD 15 - 10th with MPOA(Biology, Novel, Material Logic/Rhetoric ), Lukeion (Greek3, Latin 3)
            DS 13 - 8A with MPOA(Third Form and composition)
            DS 10 - 5M
            DS 5 - K with AAR3

            Comment


              #7
              Re: MPOA Highschool Science

              Originally posted by Mom2mthj View Post
              Katie,

              I think some of that answer will depend on your background. I have a mechanical engineering degree, so we are using the Novare ASPC book at home this year. We aren't very far into the book, but it isn't bad yet. I might recommend the introductory physics text as it uses the same experiments for the physics portion and doesn't overlap with the chemistry book. Memoria Press now has streaming videos for biology (but lesson plans/tests/study guide aren't quite ready) so there is help coming for biology. Chemistry is where I plan to have my daughter take an online science class. I say that because I don't see homeschool helps from MP for chemistry in time for your son or my daughter given how much time it has taken to develop the biology program. I haven't had chemistry since freshman year in college so I think my daughter will get much more out of chemistry with someone who has had time to prepare explain it to them. I think classes for any of the sciences would be good, but another two day/week class didn't fit into our schedule this year.
              The MPOA Chemistry teacher is excellent! She tutored my daughter in chemistry, and she teaches at HLS-Indy. I overhear her teaching the MPOA course and she is terrific. Highly recommend!
              Last edited by Cindy in Indy; 01-12-2018, 10:18 AM.
              Cindy Davis
              Science and Math teacher at Highlands Latin School - Indianapolis
              ds-24 college graduate: working, reading, writing
              ds-23 college graduate: 1st year med school
              dd-21 college junior: Nursing

              Comment


                #8
                Re: MPOA Highschool Science

                Originally posted by Mom2mthj View Post
                Katie,

                If biology is your personal strength I would suggest starting there instead of the introductory physics book (or ASPC). ASPC and physics first is great, but realistically it does add in an extra year to a typical high school science sequence. What I really like about Novare is they pare the material down to a level that kids can actually master in a year. As much as I love science it tends to go a bit slower around here because it requires more of my time. I would suggest purchasing the MP streaming video even though you could teach it. I think Tanya said the biology guide would be done by fall. Your time is valuable and those videos will help him keep on track even if you are busy. We used something similar for algebra for similar reasons...my daughter didn't want to have to wait around for a lesson. We did a biology lab intensive this fall with college prep science (formerly Landry academy) for biology because they were in our area and it was important to me that she have some hands on experience for labs. Chemistry through MPOA could be a good fit. I don't know that he needs the advanced track for chemistry. I would spend the physics time on a trig based year and a Calc based year. You have a bit of time to figure those out ;-)
                I second this recommendation. Since your son has a "big interest and talent in understanding physics and engineering", and there is not a course (DVD streaming or online) for ASPC yet, I would pass on Introductory Physics (and ASPC) and move to the biology, chemistry, advanced physics sequence, perhaps using community college in 11th and 12th grade to boost his support.
                Last edited by Cindy in Indy; 01-12-2018, 10:16 AM.
                Cindy Davis
                Science and Math teacher at Highlands Latin School - Indianapolis
                ds-24 college graduate: working, reading, writing
                ds-23 college graduate: 1st year med school
                dd-21 college junior: Nursing

                Comment

                Working...
                X